Video

-"Smoke-Out Party" interviews
-Early March interviews

-"Smoke-Out Party" interviews
-Early March interviews

Anti Ban Background

Where's the opposition?

I must admit, this ban took me off guard. I really didn't think that New York City of all places, land of bystander apathy, would open its arms to a law that takes away basic personal freedoms. So I talked to a few people to find out when and how this law came into place and if there has been any opposition to it.

Pro Ban Background

Clean City, Clean Air

New York City has long been known as the "city that never sleeps," but much of the city's nightlife character is slowly diminishing, from the peep shows in Times Square to the gentrification of the once seedy East Village. For all the nostalgic ones sorry to see them go, there are many more that have always seen them more as character flaws, and are overjoyed at their disappearance.

Profile

Case Study:
The Raven Cafe

There are many bars in New York City and each will have its own way of dealing with the smoking ban. We've decided to set camp in the East Village at a typical neighborhood bar, the Raven Cafe. In this section you will see what it's like at the bar before, durning and after the ban goes into effect.

Top News:

End of the Stay: Okay, it has finally happened. New York City has been living smoke free for almost a whole month. Well, kind of anyway. After Bloomberg's anti-smoking ban took effect March 30, 2003, most bars and restaurants have asked their smoking patronage to kindly step outside. Click here for full story...

Winter has been harsh on New Yorkers this year and on March 30, 2003, for New Yorkers who smoke, it will become even harsher. That's when it smoking in bars or restaurants will be completely outlawed. This issue is large and complex and has developed some controversy along the way.

We are Diana Nikkah and Joseph Van Harken, two students at the Columbia University Graduate School of Journalism and to help understand this issue, on February 5 we attended a public debate hosted by Justice Talking in association with National Public Radio at Baruch College.

The two sides were presented by Joseph Cherner, president of SmokeFree Educational Services, Inc. and founder of BREATHE, Bar and Restaurant Employees Advocating Together for a Healthy Environment, and by Jacob Sullum, senior editor at Reason, a libertarian magazine and a syndicated columnist. Here, many topics were discussed but the arguments distilled to two basic points:

  • Pro-Ban: no employee should have to be subjugated to conditions that compromise their health, in this case second hand smoke
  • Anti-Ban: bar and restaurant owners should have the choice to decide if their establishment will be smoke free

During the question and answer portion of the debate, one vocal bar owner, Harold Kramer who owns the Raven Café located at the corner of 12th and Avenue A, expressed concern regarding possible loss of business as a result of the ban. He noted his affiliation with a group called E.X.H.A.L.E. Following up with Mr. Kramer, we learned that the group was fictitious, but that there are a group of proprietors who are organizing to fight the ban.

Site mission: Because Kramer is an active voice opposing the ban and because his bar exemplifies the characteristics of a typical New York neighborhood bar, we have decided to profile it over the next two months in three stages: March 1-29, or the Waiting to Exhale period, March 30-April 1 or The Day the Music Died, and finally April 2- 30 or the 28 Days of Rehab. Below you will find background information on both sides, pro and anti smoking ban, and a link to the section that will profile the bar. The profile section will include the three stages told in text, photos and video and a message board for you to post your own thoughts.

Thank you, I hope you enjoy our reporting and if you have any questions, please email us directly.

--Diana Nikkah and Joseph Van Harken